View on Amazon

A Deep Dive into YouTube Music, Spotify Premium, and Apple Music: A 2025 Perspective

Streaming music has become a staple of modern life, with platforms like YouTube Music, Spotify Premium, and Apple Music vying for our ears. Each service boasts unique features, but for the average listener, they’re more alike than different. After recently revisiting YouTube Music—spurred by a family feud over a Spotify Premium plan—I’ve spent time comparing these three giants. Here’s a breakdown of their strengths, quirks, and what might sway you toward one over the others in 2025.

View on Amazon

The Big Picture: They’re All Pretty Similar

Let’s be real: YouTube Music, Spotify Premium, and Apple Music deliver the core experience we all want. You open the app, search for a song, hit play, and your phone pumps out the tunes. You can create playlists, like or dislike tracks, and discover new music. The differences lie in the details—UI, algorithms, pricing, and extras. For most people, the best choice boils down to what’s cheapest or most convenient. If your mother-in-law’s covering Spotify Premium, jump on that. If you’re a student, grab those discounts. If Verizon throws in Apple Music, take it. But if you’re paying out of pocket, here’s how they stack up.

View on Amazon

YouTube Music: Cleaner UI, Unique Content, and YouTube Premium Perks

I hadn’t touched YouTube Music in years, mostly because its early UI felt clunky. But in 2025, it’s come a long way. The interface feels cleaner than Spotify’s, especially on the “Now Playing” page. The album art takes center stage, with a simple queue bar for managing what’s next. Unlike Spotify, which sometimes pushes distracting 10-second vertical video loops from music videos (often poorly optimized), YouTube Music lets you toggle seamlessly between audio and music videos without forcing visuals on you.

One standout feature is its integration with YouTube’s vast library. If you’re into remixes, mashups, or fan-made covers—like Samuel Kim’s epic blends of Batman, anime, and Star Wars scores—YouTube Music has you covered. These tracks, often absent from Spotify or Apple Music, are easily accessible and downloadable for offline use. As a YouTube Premium subscriber, I used to bounce between the YouTube app for these tracks and Spotify for traditional music. Now, YouTube Music consolidates everything, which is a game-changer for niche listeners.

Another perk: if you’re a YouTube Premium user, you get YouTube Music bundled in. Premium also means ad-free podcasts, like our Talos of Tech and Evie show, which face ads on Spotify or Apple Podcasts due to third-party hosting. For creators like me, YouTube’s monetization system is a lifeline, and Premium subscribers actually boost our earnings per view compared to ad-supported views.

Downside: Audio quality. YouTube Music’s bitrate has been criticized, and while mowing my lawn for hours, I noticed slightly less detail in the highs compared to Spotify or Apple Music. It’s not a dealbreaker—especially through AirPods or car speakers—but audiophiles might cringe.

View on Amazon

Spotify Premium: The Recommendation King

Spotify’s algorithm is the gold standard. It digs deep into your listening habits, unearthing niche artists you’d never find otherwise. Many of my favorite bands came from Spotify’s recommendations, which feel bolder and more precise than YouTube Music’s. YouTube Music often leans on safe, nostalgic picks (think early 2000s hits like “Shooting Stars” or, embarrassingly, Justin Bieber bops) based on recent plays. Spotify, meanwhile, takes risks, suggesting obscure tracks that align with your tastes.

The UI, though, feels busier than YouTube Music’s. The baked-in lyrics and video tab can be distracting, and I’ve had issues with shared accounts—like when my wife’s playlist randomly hijacked mine. (There’s probably a setting to fix this, but it wasn’t intuitive.) Spotify’s also experimenting with a TikTok-style video platform, which could either enhance or clutter the experience, depending on execution.

Apple Music: Clean, Pricey, and Audiophile-Friendly

Apple Music’s UI is the sleekest of the bunch, with a minimalist design that puts YouTube Music and Spotify to shame. It’s also the priciest at $10.99/month (or $109/year), though its lossless audio and spatial audio support make it the go-to for audiophiles. The difference in sound quality isn’t night-and-day for casual listeners like me, but it’s noticeable if you’re using high-end gear.

Apple’s recommendations feel more human-curated, often leaning progressive. They once suggested Indian music I’d never have explored, which stuck with me despite not being my usual genre. It’s less mainstream than YouTube Music’s pop-heavy picks but not as laser-focused as Spotify’s algorithm. If you want to be challenged with new sounds, Apple Music delivers, though it might miss the mark for some.

Pricing and Value

• Spotify Premium: $9.99/month for individuals, with a Duo plan for two accounts at a slight premium. Great for couples or friends splitting the cost.

• Apple Music: $10.99/month or $109/year. No Duo plan, but student discounts are available.

• YouTube Music: Bundled with YouTube Premium at $11.99/month (or $120/year, equating to $10/month). Sign up via the web to avoid app store fees. The family plan ($23/month) is split across six people, dropping to under $5/month per person—a steal for ad-free YouTube and music.

YouTube Premium’s value shines if you’re a heavy YouTube viewer. Ads are increasingly intrusive (double ads, anyone?), and Premium eliminates them while enabling background play and offline downloads. I’ve canceled Netflix, Prime, and iCloud but kept YouTube Premium because I spend hours daily on YouTube. For music alone, Spotify or Apple might edge out, but YouTube’s all-in-one ecosystem is hard to beat.

Transferring Playlists

Switching services? I used a free app called FreeYourMusic to transfer 100 songs (up to 300 with an email signup) between Spotify and YouTube Music. It’s intuitive, requiring only account logins, and saved me hours of manual playlist rebuilding.

The Ad Block Dilemma

A quick note on ad blockers: they hurt creators. Low ad revenue (CPMs) pushes YouTube to cram in more ads, which encourages creators to lean on sponsorships. If everyone uses ad blockers, expect more in-video brand deals. YouTube Premium sidesteps this, benefiting both viewers and creators.

Final Thoughts

You can’t go wrong with any of these services. Spotify excels in discovery, Apple Music in audio quality and UI, and YouTube Music in unique content and YouTube integration. I’m sticking with YouTube Music for its mashup access and Premium perks, but Spotify’s algorithm and Apple’s polish are tempting. Pick what fits your budget and habits—whether it’s a family plan, student discount, or carrier perk. Let me know your favorite in the comments, and thanks for supporting the channel!

View on Amazon