Why the American Dream Feels Broken for an Entire Generation

Buy from Amazon

In 1985, the typical American family managed their household budget with relative predictability. Fast forward to 2022, and the economic landscape has shifted dramatically, particularly for younger generations like Millennials and Gen Z. While many expenses have scaled with inflation, some costs—rent, healthcare, childcare, and retirement savings—have surged far beyond inflation rates, creating unprecedented financial strain. This article explores the evolving economic challenges faced by young Americans, the rise of consumer debt, and the shifting definition of the American Dream.

Shop now

Rising Costs Outpacing Inflation

A comparison of a mock 1985 household budget to a hypothetical 2022 budget reveals stark differences. While most expenses have increased in line with inflation, rent, healthcare, and childcare costs have skyrocketed. For instance, rent out-of-pocket expenses, even when adjusted for inflation, are significantly higher in 2022. Healthcare costs have similarly ballooned, and childcare has become a major financial burden for young families. Retirement savings requirements have also surged by over 60%, putting additional pressure on younger generations to plan for the future.

Buy now

The Consumer Debt Explosion

One critical factor not captured in standard budgets is the rise of consumer debt. In December 1985, total outstanding consumer credit in the U.S. was approximately $600 billion. By 2022, this figure had ballooned to nearly $4.9 trillion. Student loans, virtually nonexistent for Baby Boomers, have become a defining burden for Millennials and Gen Z. These generations also face larger mortgages and car payments compared to their parents. Freddie Smith, a former actor turned realtor, highlighted the housing market’s challenges in 2023, noting that median home prices hit $420,000 with 7% interest rates, requiring a $120,000 income to qualify. This escalation in debt and housing costs makes saving for long-term goals like homeownership or retirement increasingly difficult.

Airfryer

The Phantom Wealth Phenomenon

Despite some positive economic trends—Millennials’ net worth quadrupled from $3.9 trillion to nearly $16 trillion between 2019 and 2024—many still struggle. Over half of millennials report living paycheck to paycheck, even with rising wages and a strong job market. The wealth gained, often tied to homeownership during the pandemic, is largely “phantom wealth”—value on paper that doesn’t translate to financial security. Rachel Schneider, co-author of The Financial Diaries, observed significant income volatility among the 235 families she studied, with hourly workers facing unpredictable earnings week to week. This volatility undermines traditional budgeting advice and exacerbates financial instability.

Buy now

The Elusive American Dream

The American Dream, once attainable for Baby Boomers and Gen X, feels out of reach for many Millennials and Gen Z. Homeownership, a cornerstone of this dream, is increasingly unattainable. In the 1980s, the median first-time homebuyer was in their late 20s, able to pay off a 30-year mortgage by retirement. By 2024, the median first-time homebuyer age rose to 38, an all-time high, driven by a national housing shortage, high rent prices, and competition from wealthier buyers. Rising home prices have outpaced income growth, making down payments harder to save for. As Schneider notes, many young adults are forced to live with roommates, commute long distances, or forgo starting families due to these economic pressures.

Economic Instability and Systemic Challenges

Young Americans face a new kind of economic instability, compounded by unpredictable costs and income fluctuations. Tariffs introduced in recent years have added uncertainty, potentially increasing the cost of basic goods and disproportionately affecting lower-income households. Businesses, hesitant to hire amid economic uncertainty, contribute to a cautious job market. Meanwhile, traditional financial advice—like saving six months of expenses—feels unattainable for many. Schneider emphasizes that financial struggles are often not the result of individual failings but of systemic societal choices.

The Decline of the Middle Class

For Millennials and Gen Z, the middle class lifestyle once achievable with a modest income now often requires a six-figure salary. The “big three” expenses—housing, student loan debt, and childcare—create a financial trifecta that hinders wealth-building. As Smith observes, even high-achieving young professionals, like a 29-year-old lawyer earning $80,000, struggle to afford independent living. The notion that overspending (e.g., on “avocado toast”) is the root cause oversimplifies the issue. Instead, structural challenges like stagnant wages relative to living costs and a tough job market are the primary culprits.

Pathways Forward: Practical Advice and Societal Shifts

Despite these challenges, there are strategies young Americans can adopt:

• Embrace Saving Habits: Instead of succumbing to lifestyle creep after a raise, maintain current spending levels and save the difference. Even a small financial cushion can reduce stress and provide flexibility.

• Upskill for Competitiveness: Online courses, certifications, and degrees offer accessible ways to enhance job prospects and income potential.

• Rethink Homeownership: While homeownership remains a valuable long-term investment, renting or cohabitating with friends can reduce costs. Creative solutions, like shared childcare among families, can also alleviate financial burdens.

• Advocate for Systemic Change: Recognize that financial struggles are often systemic. Supporting policies that address housing shortages, student debt, and childcare costs can create broader change.

Schneider highlights the potential for community-driven solutions, such as cohabitation or shared childcare, which can foster stronger social bonds while addressing financial constraints. However, she stresses that societal change is slow, and individuals must navigate the current system as best they can.

Conclusion

The economic reality for young Americans in 2022 is markedly different from that of 1985. Rising consumer debt, skyrocketing housing and childcare costs, and income volatility have reshaped the financial landscape, making traditional milestones like homeownership and financial stability harder to achieve. While personal strategies like saving and upskilling can help, the root issues require systemic solutions. As the U.S. grapples with potential economic challenges, including a forecasted recession, addressing these structural barriers is crucial to restoring a sense of economic opportunity for younger generations.

Subscribe to my email newsletter now.

Listen to my articles now. Click the below link

Listen now

Buy my latest book on Amazon from here. Buy from Amazon

Affiliate Disclaimer:
This article may contain affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you if you click through and make a purchase. As an affiliate, I only recommend products and services that I genuinely believe will add value to your holiday season. Your support helps me continue to create helpful content—thank you!